No More “Permanent Residency” for me!

Immigration Benefit?

After residing in the Philippines for almost 5 years, I have come to evaluate the real benefit of holding permanent residency in the Philippines, and in reality, there is NO real benefit other than establishing a requirement of residency. One that may be required under certain circumstances with financial institutions to open an account or maybe Driver’s Licensing and insurance requirements. It doesn’t even entitle foreigners to the privilege of having a “Senior Citizen ID Card!” It damn sure doesn’t provide you with additional judicial or human rights!

For me, it has become a burden, not in the sense of an inconvenience or anything, but rather it is costing me more money than I anticipated. (Note: everyone’s immigration status can be different, therefore there is no “one-size-fits-all” solution.)

When I obtained my 13A visa (which is permanent) at the Philippine consulate in Chicago, there was a cost. Upon arrival in the Philippines and clearing the Bureau of Quarantine came with a cost. Then at the Bureau of Immigration (BI) applying for the permanent ACR-I card (Alien Certificate of Registration) there were more costs. All-in-all the total cost to obtain my “permanent”ACR card was about P14,000 (back when the exchange rate was 43-1). Initially I thought this was not bad because the “Annual Reporting” fee was only P310 per year for the next 4 years, and overall it would be cheaper than going with the “Tourist Visa” that requires repeated extensions costing money, or the “Balikbayan Privilege” which requires yearly travel outside the country when you least feel like traveling, also costing money. The total costs of having the permanent ACR card, including the annual fees, would be considered reasonable… if you never traveled anywhere outside the country.

During my first 4 1/2 years being Retired in Samar, I traveled outside the country 7 times. Each time I exited through Immigration at the airport I had to  pay for my Exit Clearance and Re-entry Permit, costing P2,880 (and P2,280 for subsequent trips made during the same calendar year). So in my case for that period, I had spent at least P18,960, not including airport departure fees, hotel costs, and travel costs to and from from Samar, just for the “privilege” of having permanent residency.


Decision Time. 

Initially, we never forseen all this travel. We thought we would settle down and never leave (at least not that many times). Since then, and because my wife and I have decided to do a little more traveling in the future, I have concluded that it will be much more beneficial to avail of the “Balikbayan  Privilege” rather than holding a permanent ACR card, so I since decided to give up my Non-Quota Immigrant status and the permanent ACR card. But it’s not that easy!

As of this writing and prior to traveling – because my ACR card was set to expire in a couple of months, I was ‘informed’ that if I left and returned to the Philippines with an expired card, there would be fines and fees. So I decided I’d simply surrender my card before I left the country. And because just any Immigration office wouldn’t do, it required a trip to the main BI in Intramuros (Manila). I would just plan to arrive in Manila early and simply (this word ‘simply’ should not exist in the English-Tagalog dictionary) drop by the BI before heading to the airport to catch our flight to Guam. My thought was to surrender the card so I could save on the Exit/Re-entry fee at the airport and the penalty and fees for returning with an expired card. 

Come dressed properly!

First, I must have become an idiot since I retired here because I arrived at the BI wearing shorts and flip-flops. My shorts were accepted by the gatekeeper, but the slippers were a no-no. (I’d left home and forgot to pack my shoes.) Whoever said that the BI had relaxed the dress code was obviously delusional or intoxicated on Facebook! Not only did the BI NOT allow me to enter, they also denied my wife entry based on her wearing shorts… and she had on nice shorts! So, rather than “rent” a pair of skanky shoes on the street outside (yes, there are actually shoe-rental vendors who prey on us idiot foreigners), we took a short trip across the river to the Divisoria Market where I acquired me a brand new pair of “Nike Zooms” for P500 ($10). Knock-offs obviously – but they do look nice. 

Inside the BI.

I dropped the wife wearing shorts off at Jollibee’s to wait for me while I went back to the BI. If you think the application process to obtain an ACR card is a royal pain in the ass, you should try cancelling one! Inside the BI, I was directed to window 10, then was referred to window 21, then window 6… and finally window 1. Whenever you start going ‘window-backwards’ at the BI, you can plan on extending your stay a little longer. I eventually wound up at window 5 and received the best advice I could have gotten… “just go to the airport and get on the plane and worry about the expired ACR card when you return.”  And it only took 45 minutes to get that advice!

Okay, originally my plan was to surrender my ACR card downgrading myself to “tourist” status, then going to the airport and NOT having to pay the P2,880 Exit/re-entry fee. But nothing is as easy as it seems in the Philippines. Initially the lady at window 21 told me I would first need a “notarized” letter requesting cancellation of my ACR card. But in order to do that, I would also need another “notorized” letter from the attorney to downgrade my 13A visa (Not really a downgrade per se as the 13A is permanent, but simply a process that disassociates my 13A from my non-quota immigrant status.) So, back outside I went to obtain the two attorney prepared and notorized letters (and copies) which cost me P340.

Inside and back at window 21, I was informed that it will take approximately 2-3 business days to effect the ‘visa downgrade’ and ACR card cancellation (apparently she did not hear me correctly when I told her I had a plane to catch that evening!)  When I again explained that my flight was leaving in about 12 hours, that is when the musical windows saga began. From one to the next, each time explaining my situation. Then when I eventually got to window 1, the nice immigration lady tells me we could probably get it done same day but then drops this on me – I would likely incur a cost of between P3,000-P4,000 (express fee). It was at this time that I had the thought of loudly yelling “I Quit” whilst slamming my card down on the counter and walking out (it was just a fleeting thought). In reality though, I would never be allowed to leave the country without it, or at least it would lead to a big time hassle. When I finally arrived at window 5 again for another “consultation,” I learned that when I am downgraded to “Tourist Visa” status, I would then need an “Exit Clearance Certificate (ECC)” (because I would now be a tourist) which would take a minimum of 72 hours to process. It was at this point that I finally realized why many expats go bald in this country… it’s not from the bagoong and beer and noise, it’s from pulling their hair out manually! @#!*&%

This is when I asked the nice Immigration lady “What would happen if I just went to the airport, got on the plane and left?” She replied “Nothing sir. When you return, just smile and be nice to the Immigration officer and ask for a Balikbayan Stamp and your ACR card will automatically become voided.” Aughhh!

Spanish Colonial Period Jail

If I had only listened to my own instincts, I would have saved about $32 which was the round-trip GRAB ride to Intramuros (P453), attorney’s fees (P340), round trip trike ride to Divisoria (P240), Nike Zoom knock-offs (P500), a pair of socks (P49) and a Jollibee’s chocolate sundae ((P39) because coffee was out of stock).

But hey, at least we did get to see the old Spanish Jail while we were in Intramuros! And if you ever need to feel like a rock star, just exit the BI wearing flip-flops… you will receive instant attention!

These days my wife and I have been residing in Guam and travel back and forth to our home in Samar at will, using only the Balikbayan Privilege. It’s so much easier and stress free. Live and Learn as they say!

If you found this post entertaining or helpful, I would gladly accept you buying me a cup of coffee! Your donations are what helps keep this site going. Thank You so much!

Please “SHARE” this post to help me reach more subscribers.

Follow me @


#philippines #guam #islandlife #livinginthepacific #samar #expats #expatlife #islandvibes #liveinthephilippines #westpac #retirement #asia #filipina #filipino #ACR #balikbayanprivilege #philippinesvisa




5 thoughts on “No More “Permanent Residency” for me!

  1. Interesting news about the dress code. I sent immigration a message to see if there has been any updates or changes to Administrative Circular No. SBM-2013-007 that was issued on 01 October 2013 revising the policy on dress code. That version allowed the use of slippers/ flip flops. I’ll update you if/when I get a response.

  2. Thanks for that Gary. Seems to me most rules are so convoluted even the authorities struggle with them at times. What I was told at the Immigration office in Calbayog City did not hold true with the main BI in Manila. That said, it’s hard to be completely prepared for anything, ha ha. Looking forward to see IF you even get a response. Thanks again for the comment.

  3. I received a response today from the BOI Facebook account. According to that there has been no updates to the Circular and slippers/ flip flops are allowed. I’ll be testing this in April when I go to Intramuros to renew my ACR card April.

  4. My thoughts on using fb as an “official” source is like trusting the guy at the front door at the BI to know the rules! I would’t take the chance… I’m glad you will let the rest of us know! lol

  5. The benefits are for the government, as usual. They just want your money in exchange for a pass that you don’t have to renew every 2 months. You got out at a good time with this covid-19 virus too!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.